Emerging Markets Valuations in a Global Context

 

Successful investors are never shy to avoid expensive markets, preferring to build cash reserves to deploy when other investors are less greedy and more fearful. Much of the success of investors like Warren Buffett or Seth Klarman (Baupost) has come from having plenty of cash on hand when markets suffer cyclical downturns, like in 2000 and 2008. Klarman was once asked by a client why he should be paid his high fees for holding very large amounts of cash (sometimes well above 50%). His answer: “You are paying us to decide when to hold onto cash and when to invest.”

Well, it appears it may be happening again. It was revealed this week that Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway holds over $100 billion in cash, and Klarman also has well over a quarter of his fund in cash.  Meanwhile individual investors have reduced cash to the lowest levels since the peak of the 2000 bubble.

Buffett and Klarman are not alone. It is commonly accepted by market historians, though certainly not by technicians and momentum traders, that the U.S. market is at very high levels. This view is based on the premise that market valuations mean-revert over time in a somewhat predictable fashion. Though valuations are by no means a timing instrument, they do have a good track record of predicting long-term (5-10 years) future returns. For example, Robert Schiller’s CAPE ratio (Shiller), which measures valuations based on 10-years of inflation-adjusted earnings, currently shows extraordinarily high levels, which at least in the past have been highly predictive of  low prospective returns.

Shiller CAPE Ratio

Crestmont Capital’s extremely thorough analysis of U.S. valuation (1926-2017) history points to a near certainty of lower than normal returns from current levels. Historical U.S stock market returns of 10.0%, came from nominal earnings growth (5.1%), price-earnings multiple expansion (0.6% annually, starting from a low level of 10.2 in 1926) and dividend yield (4.3%).  Annual Real GDP growth and inflation over the period averaged 3.3% and 2.9%, respectively, both of which are currently expected to be lower over the next ten years. The table below shows Crestmont’s absolute best case forecast for market returns for the next ten years to be in the order of 7.1%, well below historical levels. Earnings growth is optimistically assumed to grow 5.1%, in line with history, even though GDP growth and inflation are both likely to be lower. Price-earnings ratios are assumed to remain at the current very high levels. Dividend yield is determined by current valuations. Any contraction of PE levels or lower than historical earnings growth would result in lower returns.

The logic of Shiller’s CAPE and Crestmont’s analysis leads to forecasts of low expected returns for U.S. equities, and all other asset classes impacted by similar factors. For example, relying on historical analysis and reversion-to-the-mean assumptions, Jeremy Grantham’s GMO  (GMO) predicts abysmally low returns for almost all of the asset classes it follows.

Similar analysis produced by Research Affiliates points to equally poor results for the next decade: near zero real returns for U.S. stocks, 2%+ returns for international stocks and 6%+ stocks for emerging markets:

Both GMO and Research Affiliates highlight the relative attractiveness of emerging markets equities in a very low return world. An extended period of under-performance of emerging markets relative to the U.S. market in particular has created a significant gap for investors to exploit. Not only are emerging markets cheap relative to the U.S. and other developed markets, they also are inexpensive relative to their own history. On a cyclically adjusted basis (CAPE EM), valuations in EM are still below average and very far from historical peaks, in contrast to the U.S. which is well above average and near historical peaks. Price earnings ratios  for EM, are near historical averages, in a world where most asset prices are well above historical levels.

To conclude, a further comment on U.S. valuations is in order. It can be argued that current U.S. valuations reflect the reality of extraordinarily low interest rates. The puzzle lies in determining the cause of these low rates; is it Federal Reserve manipulation?; is it deflation caused by globalization and technology?; or does it point to low real growth in real GDP and earnings  in the future caused by demographics and low productivity? The answer to this puzzle will likely explain the short term course of the U.S. market.

Us Fed watch:

India Watch:

  • India’s stock market is set for a huge bull run (Wisdom Tree)
  • Is India like East Asia or Latin America? (Livemint)

China Watch:

  • The geopolitical landscape of Asia Pacific is changing (WEF)
  • China’s ascent is slowing (Bloomberg)
  • China needs more reform to progress (Caixing)
  • Trump on the verge of trade war with China (Brookings)
  • Foreign tourists are shunning China (SCMP)

China Technology Watch:

  • China now has 751 million internet users (Caixing)
  • China is the next tech superpower (Diamandis)
  • China targets U.S. microchip hegemony (WSJ)

EM Investor Watch

  • Bangladesh’s rise to manufacturing powerhouse (FT)
  • Venezuela’s total collapse (Project Syndicate)
  • Venezuela was once Latin America’s richest country (WEFORUM)
  • Military unrest on the rise in Venezuela (Geopolitical Futures)
  • In Brazil highway robbery is a growth industry (Bloomberg)

Investor Watch:

Notable Quotes: (Avondale)

It’s a low return high risk world

  • “Markets normally respond to elevated uncertainty with lower asset prices and compensatorily higher returns. But that’s not what we are encountering today. We are living in a low-return, high risk world and an environment where most investors are happy to bear risk.” —Oaktree CEO Jay Steven Wintrob (Investment Management)

China is likely to lead the world in electrification

  • “China’s forecasted to lead the global trend in Powertrain electrification, representing over 50% of unit production in 2025, reflecting a 40 fold increase over today’s levels. We remain optimistic about the China market as a result of the underlying macro trends which include increased government focus on emissions regulations, which are increasing demand for China’s new energy vehicles” —Delphi CEO Kevin Clark (Auto Parts)

Australian Iron Ore is being sold to traders, not users

  • “what these guys are doing, these guys mean, for abundance of clarity, Fortescue, BHP and Rio Tinto, Vale and even the midget, Roy Hill, they sell to traders. And these traders do not have blast furnaces. They buy because it’s cheap to borrow money in Chinese banks. Then they put that iron ore in the ground, not in a blast furnace, at the port. And then they go back to the banks, and say, hey, I have collateral, can I borrow more? And the banker say, yes, and they borrow more, and they buy more for the same idiots…That’s my problem with the business in Australia. Then comes the question, will this be happening forever? Yes or no? Of course, the answer is no. One day, this bubble will burst. And on that day, people will say, oh, we are surprised that we are not seeing iron ore inventories going up.” —Cliffs Natural Resources CEO Lourenco Goncalves (Iron Ore)

Notable Charts: